FORTH SMART SERVICE PUBLIC COMPANY LIMITEDSET: FSMART🇹🇭 TH

Risk Management · 2024

Risk Management Policy & Plan

Policy & Plan Description

The company places great importance on risk management by adopting the COSO (The Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission) framework, an internationally recognized standard, to manage internal risks effectively and sustainably. The company has clearly defined roles and responsibilities for personnel at all levels, including the Board of Directors, Audit Committee, Risk Management Committee, Executives, Internal Auditors, Compliance, and all employees, who are the owners of the company’s key risks and its subsidiaries. The comprehensive risk management policies and plans include

1. Risk Management Committee

The Board of Directors has appointed the Risk Management Committee to consider and approve the risk management framework, policies, and plans in alignment with legal requirements, the company's vision, mission, objectives, business goals, and strategic plans. The Risk Management Committee collaborates with the Audit Committee to oversee, monitor, and report risk management results to the Board of Directors regularly.

2. Risk Management Process

The company implements a systematic risk management process, involving the identification, analysis, and assessment of potential risks and their impacts. Appropriate risk management approaches include

• Risk Termination (Terminate)

• Risk Reduction (Reduce)

• Risk Transfer (Transfer)

• Risk Avoidance (Avoid)

3. Categories of Corporate Risks

The company focuses on managing risks across six key dimensions

• Strategic Risk

• Financial Risk

• Technology Risk

• Operational Risk

• Legal Risk

• Sustainability Risk

4. Risk Management Structure under the Three Lines of Defense Model

The company has adopted the "Three Lines of Defense" model to manage risk effectively by assigning responsibilities at three levels:

• First Line: Operational employees who directly own the risks

• Second Line: Management and Compliance, reporting to the Managing Director and Risk Management Committee

• Third Line: Internal Auditors, reporting to the Audit Committee to assess the effectiveness of risk management

5. Cultivating a Risk Management Culture

The company promotes a risk-aware culture at all levels by effectively communicating risk management policies and plans through various channels, ensuring integration into daily operations.

6. Risk Management Review and Monitoring

The company has a policy to review the risk management framework and plans at least once a year. In 2024, the Risk Management Committee conducted a review and reported to the Board of Directors by quarterly total 4 times. Additionally, ongoing monitoring of emerging risks is conducted to ensure timely updates and adjustments to risk management plans.

7. Compliance with Relevant Laws and Standards

The company operates in compliance with applicable laws and regulations, such as the Electronic Transactions Act, Payment System Act under the Bank of Thailand, Anti-Money Laundering laws, and financial regulations related to terrorism financing. The company's risk management practices are designed to meet both global standards and legal requirements.

8. Subsidiary Risk Management

Fort Smart Capital Co., Ltd., a subsidiary, has been granted approval by the Ministry of Finance through the Bank of Thailand to operate Personal Loan and Nano Finance businesses under regulatory supervision. The company is committed to conducting business with transparency, fairness, and a strong focus on consumer benefits, while implementing comprehensive and effective risk management measures. This ensures that its lending services adhere to Market Conduct principles and uphold the standards of Responsible Lending. Furthermore, the company prioritizes customers' ability to repay their debts, prevents excessive financial burdens, and promotes financial discipline—aiming to foster a stable and sustainable financial system.


The company is committed to continuously enhancing its risk management systems to address evolving business challenges and maintain long-term organizational sustainability.

Risks to the Company's Business Operations

Risk Register

Risk NameRisk CharacteristicsConsequencesManagement MeasuresRelated Risk Factors
Risk from changes in user behavior

Risk from changes in user behavior

This situation has resulted in a rapid change in consumer behavior as consumers can choose to use various channels for making phone top-up transactions or making payments such as making payment through mobile banking or mobile applications that can provide mobile phone top-up or payment services or making payment through convenience stores or purchasing prepaid scratch cards or prepaid mobile phones via ATMs, etc., to avoid the risk of spreading the virus that can arise from meeting people. In addition, for some types of services, there is a lower rate of fees or payment charges than transactions made through the Company's service channels and/or there is a channel that users can access more easily. This puts the company at risk that the Boonterm kiosk will not be as popular with users as it is today if the service user changes behavior or change the service channel to another channel in the future which will be an alternative that can meet the needs of the service users more than using the service through a top-up machine.

If customers shift their payment behavior to other channels, the number and value of transactions through the company's channels will decrease, directly impacting the company's revenue. In 2024, the company generated revenue of 372.76 million baht from of top-up service for prepaid phone and receipt of online services , representing a decrease of 8.1% compared to the previous year

The company remains committed to developing and expanding a variety of integrated service models beyond just being a payment acceptance and money transfer point through Boonterm kiosks, as follows:

• Introducing new service channels through cashier counters and applications for corporate customers, providing a seamless, convenient, and comprehensive service experience. This expansion aims to accommodate new customer groups who may not have used Boonterm services before, creating an opportunity to significantly increase the customer base.

• Enhancing identity verification services with electronic Know Your Customer (e-KYC) technology. This innovation enables remote identity authentication, replacing traditional face-to-face verification, thereby increasing the likelihood of customers utilizing Boonterm’s other services.

• Implementing payment innovations since late 2023 to the present, including the introduction of Wallet top-up services through the company’s channels. Customers now have the option to make payments by scanning a QR Code for seamless transactions.

729 · Description: Behavior or needs of customers / consumers · Info category: STRATEGIC_RISK
Risk from dependence on income from mobile phone network operators

In 2024, the market size for prepaid mobile top-up services significantly decreased compared to the previous year. Although the number of users has increased, the revenue per user has declined. The revenue from top-up services can be divided into two parts:

1) Commission revenue from providing prepaid mobile top-up services, which is income received from the two major mobile network operators in the country: AIS, DTAC, and Truemove-H. Revenue from commission fees for mobile top-up services from these major mobile network providers accounts for 17% of the total revenue from services provided through the Boonterm machines in 2024.

2) Service charge revenue from users who pay fees when performing transactions through the Boonterm machines for mobile top-ups of these two major mobile network providers. This revenue accounts for 76% of the commission revenue from services through Boonterm, or 75% of the total revenue from services provided through Boonterm in 2024.

Due to the company's significant reliance on the mobile network business, any event that causes mobile network operators to face operational issues preventing them from providing mobile services, or if they decide to revoke the company's authorization as a top-up service provider, could have a substantial impact on the company’s total revenue . Additionally, in 2024, two major mobile network operators, Truemove-H and DTAC, completed a merger,

increasing the risk of stronger bargaining power from mobile network providers.

However, the three major mobile phone network operators are considered the country's major mobile phone network operators with good financial status and have been popular with the majority of users who choose to use the service in the country. For this reason, the chance that there will be a problem in the Company's business operations with the aforementioned mobile phone network service provider is still considered to be a low level of possibility. In addition, mobile phone network operators have appointed the Company as an agent for providing payment services for goods or other services on mobile phones through the Boonterm system in order to continually expand the payment channels of the aforementioned mobile phone network operators. Therefore, the company predicts that the risk from contract termination of mobile network operators is low.

In 2024, the Company has managed the risk of relying on revenue from mobile phone network operators by developing and expanding service models to increase the proportion of revenue from payment services other than just relying on the main income from mobile top-up services alone, including comprehensive financial services of both deposit-transfer-withdraw cash through the Boonterm kiosk, electronic wallet top-up service and various utility bill payment services through the cashier counter, etc. It can be seen that the proportion of revenue from such services has increased significantly due to the expansion of services through other channels. In 2024, the company generated service revenue from automated payment terminals amounting to 1,733.05 million baht, representing an increase of 7.9% compared to the previous year.

733 · Description: Business operations of partners in the supply chain · Info category: STRATEGIC_RISK
The risk of relying on service agents (Master Agent) and business partners

Company's business operations is a form of management system and cooperation in providing the Boonterm kiosk service among the company, the service agent (Master Agent) and business partners to expand the Boonterm kiosk service point to quality areas and locations, which will cover all areas nationwide by 31 December, 2024. The company has a total more than 110,000 kiosks, divided into:

1) 86,370 Boonterm kiosks operated by service agents or 72.16% of the total Boonterm kiosks

2) Boonterm kiosks jointly managed by the company and business partners, installed at convenience stores or department stores, etc., for a total of 18,818kiosks, or 15.72% of the total number of Boonterm kiosks.

As of 31 December 2024, The company had 127 master agent which all of Thailand

Due to the risks associated with relying on service agents and business partners, as well as the declining popularity of the company's channels, the company has devised risk management plans. These plans aim to address potential issues such as service agents not complying with agreed terms, insufficient revenue leading to contract cancellation, and the impact of these on overall revenue.

As of December 31, 2024, there were a total of 127 service agents managing operations across all provinces in Thailand.

The company has implemented strategies such as conducting assessments and visits to evaluate the quality and potential of service agents in each area. Additionally, they have provided guidance and assistance to agents in managing and maintaining the top-up kiosks, ensuring continuous service availability. Furthermore, the company has enhanced revenue management efficiency by developing the service capabilities of service agents continuously, reducing various risks associated with inadequate service quality. These efforts include ensuring high-quality location procurement and effective kiosk management. Moreover, the company has established advisory systems to help service agents maximize revenue from the kiosks, fostering long-term business collaboration. Regarding kiosk management with business partners, the company has engaged in negotiations and coordination to maintain service quality consistently, minimize risks, and establish suitable profit-sharing agreements. Additionally, the company has expanded its sales team and installation units to increase kiosk service points in areas where service agents or business partners cannot reach, further reducing the risk of inaccessible kiosk locations.


733 · Description: Business operations of partners in the supply chain · Info category: STRATEGIC_RISK · 735 · Description: Reliance on large partners / distributors or few partners / distributors · Info category: STRATEGIC_RISK
Risks from technological changes

Mobile phone recharge business or various payment services are heavily dependent on technology to provide services. This may be considered a risk from technological changes. The company therefore has to set up a process to monitor and develop the technology of the mobile top-up service system and other services provided through the Boonterm kiosk to be up-to-date at all times.



Due to technological changes, customers have easier access to financial transactions. It may result in customers switching to other channels. Make the transaction amount through the company's channels and income can decrease Including the safety of customer information.

The Boonterm system has a strong point in using online data connection system technology, so it can connect the system to every Boonterm kiosk and cashier counter anywhere. The company is also able to quickly change the software system to meet the needs of the service users including being able to adjust, increase or decrease the service through the Boonterm kiosk such as introducing new services that are popular with service users through the Boonterm kiosk. The company can also take services that users do not like anymore from the Boonterm kiosk as well. Because the company has its own information technology development team (R&D) to develop service systems and/or work system programs, it is convenient and quick to add, improve and develop programs as needed. The information technology strength of the company mentioned above is a part that can help reduce the risk if compared to other service providers that use automatic payment machines from abroad or use a tablet computer ready to order which may have a chance to cause problems more easily and can be more difficult to adapt to use in the Thai market.


In 2024, the company focuses on building service quality through automatic payment machines and cashier counters of the company with comprehensive service points to increase the potential of providing better services, responding to all needs of main customers who conduct cash transactions. Moreover, it has accelerated the development of various types of automated service channels, making the company more diversified in terms of service channels, able to support service users in all target groups and also able to reduce risks from technological changes.



732 · Description: Changes in technologies · Info category: STRATEGIC_RISK
Risk from dependence on the main director Risk from reliance on high-ranking executives.

Risk from dependence on the main director: Mr. Pongchai Amatanon, the founder of the company, currently holds the position of director of the company and Chairman of the Executive Board of the Company who has been in business for a long time. He has a vision and is directly responsible for setting policies, directions and business operations of the Company.

Risk from dependence on high-ranking executives who have the potential to formulate strategies and manage the organization to meet the set goals with potential, making the company grow and penetrate the business quickly and efficiently.

Relying too heavily on individuals in key positions can lead to delays in operations and decision-making at the management level. It may also result in the company losing confidence from investors and business partners, which could negatively impact the organization's image and long-term growth plans. Furthermore, changes in top executives may affect employees within the organization, creating uncertainty in the workplace and potentially impacting employee morale.

The Company has the risk of relying on such main director. At present, the company has set up an organizational structure to appoint qualified and experienced directors in management and business operations. And the company has high-level executives who have the potential to formulate strategies and manage the organization to achieve the organization's goals well. This is to manage the risk of relying on the main directors to be at a low level.

The company plans to decentralize management power by requiring executives at various levels to participate more in decision-making and determining the direction of the company's business operations, having clear authority and responsibility for various tasks and having the authority to make decisions and perform detailed actions within the specified scope. Also, the Company has provided appropriate succession plan management and career path development to reduce the risk of dependence on the company's senior management to be at a low level..

738 · Description: Reliance on employees in key positions · Info category: OPERATIONAL_RISK · 739 · Description: Shortage or reliance on skilled workers · Info category: OPERATIONAL_RISK
Operating system security risks

The Company operates an electronic service business through the Boonterm kiosk by using technology and information technology systems as the main mechanism to drive the business. It is inevitable to face the risk of technological threats. The company recognizes the importance of technology due to the challenges from intense competition and the rapid growth of technology that is coupled with cyber threats. This may cause damage to business operations and the confidence of service users, whether in terms of providing services or maintaining customer confidentiality.

If the company's system is attacked, it could face significant expenses for data recovery and system repairs. Additionally, system disruptions may lead to a decrease in revenue, as customers would be unable to access services as usual, which could impact the company's competitive performance and trust in the organization.

However, in 2024, the company did not experience any incidents of data breaches resulting from cyberattacks, demonstrating the effectiveness of the ongoing information technology security measures implemented by the company.

The company, therefore, has strict and concise security measures against cyber threats by setting up both a regulatory framework and risk management in terms of personnel, processes and tools used in operations including the internal audit process and from outside auditors and from service licensors to prepare for dealing with cyber threats. The company has established a cyber threat preparedness assessment framework and risk management guidelines with security and safety control measures such as network segmentation, data encryption, personnel training, proper firewall settings, choosing a program to protect against malware or ransomware and the use of multiple factors to verify a person's identity, etc. To enhance readiness to deal with cyber threats. The company remains committed to developing the most robust cybersecurity and auditing processes to address any and all potential risks.

744 · Description: Information security and cyber-attack · Info category: OPERATIONAL_RISK
Legal risks related to business operations.

The company faces risks from non-compliance with laws related to electronic payment services and electronic money services, as well as the potential for misinterpretation of legal provisions that may lead to misunderstandings. Additionally, there are risks associated with non-compliance with personal data protection laws (PDPA), which could arise from the use of customer data without proper or complete consent. The company also faces risks related to providing personal loan services under the supervision of Fort Smart Capital Co., Ltd., which must comply with laws regarding loans and credit information.

If the company fails to fully comply with the relevant laws, it may face risks of penalties or the potential revocation of its business license. Additionally, improper use of personal data could damage the company’s reputation and create legal risks from potential lawsuits by users. There is also the risk of violating laws related to loans and credit information, which could impact the company’s business credit.

Under the supervision and compliance with the regulations and guidelines related to payment systems, personal loan services under supervision, credit information laws, and the Personal Data Protection Act (PDPA), the company must adhere to strict requirements. The company places great importance on protecting customer data during every transaction. It fully complies with the PDPA, including establishing policies for the collection, use, and disclosure of personal data, which must be done with customer consent. Access to data is restricted by authorized personnel, and the use of data is limited to company activities. Every process is closely monitored by both the company’s risk management and regulatory bodies, including the Bank of Thailand for cybersecurity (Cyber Hygiene) and the Office of the Personal Data Protection Commission (PDPC), as well as external IT auditors. This ensures transparency in the use of customer data. The company’s operations allow for auditing, review, and tracking of every process, ensuring that customer data is used appropriately in accordance with the consented purposes, effectively and efficiently. This approach differentiates the company from others, which may face risks related to the misuse of personal data in cases of non-compliance with legal and regulatory requirements.

756 · Description: Change in laws and regulations · Info category: COMPLIANCE_RISK · 757 · Description: Laws and regulations is not favorable for doing business · Info category: COMPLIANCE_RISK · 758 · Description: Violations of laws and regulations · Info category: COMPLIANCE_RISK · 759 · Description: Corporate Governance · Info category: COMPLIANCE_RISK
Risk from dependence on financial institutions

As of December 31, 2024, the company still borrows money from financial institutions for business use. The financial institution will have conditions requiring the Company to maintain certain financial ratios according to the conditions specified in the loan agreement. And the company can comply with the specified conditions appropriately.

In 2024, the Company is still exposed to the risk of interest rate volatility related to loans. Even though the company has no long-term credit obligations with financial institutions. Utilizing short-term loans to support the expansion of subsidiary companies may increase the company's financial costs.


However, in 2024, the company has not been affected by the increase in financial costs due to fluctuations in loan interest rates and has continued to comply with the terms of short-term loan agreements.

However, the company still has the ability to pay dividends in the amount of more than 173 million baht or 40 % of net profit, which can well reflect the strength of the company's financial status. Therefore, the risk of relying on funding from financial institutions is very low.

761 · Description: Insufficient sources of funding · Info category: FINANCIAL_RISK · 762 · Description: Change in financial and investment policies of financial institutions that affect business operations · Info category: FINANCIAL_RISK · 1724 · Description: Liquidity risk · Info category: FINANCIAL_RISK
The risk of loss and damage of the Boonterm kiosks

The fact that the company has to bring the Boonterm kiosk which is the main asset in the business operation of the company to be installed at service points in various areas across the country in order to support the service for users to be able to use the service conveniently and quickly every day, 24 hours a day, resulting in the company being at risk of loss and damage of the Boonterm kiosk. In addition, the electronic payment service of the Boonterm kiosk operates in cash. The cash received from the service must be stored in the Boonterm kiosk for a short period of time before the service representative of the company opens the kiosk and collects the money to deliver to the company. As a result, such cash is at risk of being stolen or be tampered

Boonterm kiosks are company assets. Any damage, such as the loss of the kiosk or the cash inside, negatively impacts the company's assets. If a kiosk becomes inoperable, repairs are necessary, leading to increased company expenses. Additionally, such issues may undermine the confidence of partners who manage Boonterm kiosks for revenue generation.


The company has continually developed and improved the security system of the Boonterm kiosks. At present, the company has developed and installed a tamper or theft prevention system with sensors and sirens that will send a loud alarm when there is a tamper, bump or smash of the Boonterm kiosk. At the same time, the system will send an alert signal to the central office through the Boonterm Call Center, telephone number 1220, in order to notify relevant persons in a timely manner. In addition, the company also collects monthly insurance from all service agents by deducting from the compensation that the service agent will receive in order to be a reserve for managing the risk of loss and damage of the Boonterm kiosk as well.

The company has team to proactively track and apprehend criminals and malicious individuals involved in vandalism or attempts to steal or dismantle kiosks to access cash inside. Furthermore, they installed security equipment and implemented measures to reduce the occurrence of robberies in high-risk areas. This also involved implementing legally effective processes. Additionally, the company established maximum transaction limits to mitigate the risk of cash loss in kiosks. Consequently, the risk of loss and damage to recharge kiosks was kept at a minimal level.

1721 · Description: Inventory risk · Info category: OPERATIONAL_RISK
Risks for Delays in the development of future projects

In the year 2024, the company began operating a business providing electric vehicle charging services under the brand GINKA Charge Point, offering AC Type chargers, which are standard chargers. Despite the relatively low number of electric vehicles in Thailand compared to the market, the electric vehicle charging industry faces significant competition from numerous players, including major service providers who have entered the market with similar offerings. This poses a risk that the new venture initiated by the company may not meet initial expectations.

The company has invested in the GINKA Charge Point AC-type electric vehicle charging service, suitable for enclosed areas such as residences or condominiums. However, this type of charger requires longer charging times, which may not meet customer needs, potentially leading to low adoption rates. If the company invests in GINKA Charge Point DC-type chargers, it faces significant competition from numerous competitors who have already installed such chargers in various locations. This situation may hinder the company's ability to promptly install chargers in popular areas. Additionally, rapid advancements in electric vehicle technology are enabling future models to travel longer distances, potentially decreasing the frequency of charging required.

The company has innovated and developed a sleek design with a smart cable management system, featuring a retractable cable that prevents the cable from touching the ground and allows for easy storage. This helps keep the charging cable clean, enabling users to access the charging port quickly, cleanly, and safely. The system is user-friendly and simple, with a touch-screen display. There is no need to install a mobile app, and users will receive SMS notifications when charging is complete. The system offers multiple payment options, and users can also use credit balance stored in their phone number for future transactions, creating a unique selling point compared to competitors. The company is also progressing with the development of DC Type fast-charging electric vehicle chargers to provide faster services in the future. Additionally, there is a parking fee management system for vehicles that have completed charging but have not been moved from the charging station, addressing the issue of vehicles parked but not charging, or fully charged vehicles that are not moved. Customers will not be able to remove their vehicle unless they have paid the parking fee.

The company places great emphasis on reviewing, planning, and implementing proactive policies during crises to help the organization achieve its goals while mitigating new risks that could impact the business. This is done alongside responding to the needs of customers and other stakeholders, with the goal of sustainable development. The company also regularly reports operational results to the Risk Management Committee and the Board of Directors on a quarterly basis.

746 · Description: Delays in the development of future projects · Info category: OPERATIONAL_RISK · 1716 · Description: New business risk · Info category: STRATEGIC_RISK
Contents